I have this game unplayed on my shelf, so I can’t comment on your points, other than to say it’s refreshing to hear a detailed critique of WHY you didn’t like it. Too many reviews that are somewhat… ummm… negative don’t do that
I’m always thinking someone put a lot of work into this and it deserves attention. Also as I said in the introduction, if I don't reflect on it, how am I going to take anything away from it myself or possibly even the author or other designers
Good points there.. I haven’tplayed the game. But as Paul said, you didn’t blacken this game but you gave your own personal thoughts and those were true. I think one has to be honest in reviews. No point making everything to gold… everyone has their own idea of what works and don’t. And if any mechanics seems strange it would be nice to hear more of these from other players.
Thank you for this review! I like how you did it. For me it is perfectly fine to have an own opinion and actually this is what I am - as a reader - interested in. I think you also found a balanced way to the assessment. Especially because you referred - and you are aware - of positive reviews. Thanks and have a good weekend!
I have this game unplayed on my shelf, so I can’t comment on your points, other than to say it’s refreshing to hear a detailed critique of WHY you didn’t like it. Too many reviews that are somewhat… ummm… negative don’t do that
I’m always thinking someone put a lot of work into this and it deserves attention. Also as I said in the introduction, if I don't reflect on it, how am I going to take anything away from it myself or possibly even the author or other designers
Good points there.. I haven’tplayed the game. But as Paul said, you didn’t blacken this game but you gave your own personal thoughts and those were true. I think one has to be honest in reviews. No point making everything to gold… everyone has their own idea of what works and don’t. And if any mechanics seems strange it would be nice to hear more of these from other players.
Thank you for this review! I like how you did it. For me it is perfectly fine to have an own opinion and actually this is what I am - as a reader - interested in. I think you also found a balanced way to the assessment. Especially because you referred - and you are aware - of positive reviews. Thanks and have a good weekend!